I love you, too. Is exactly what she means when she tells him she likes watching him right back. She's never stopped liking watching him. She never will either.
Some people might say there's something almost as terrifying as a but followed a pause, and that's an, I think. Or some form of it like, I've been thinking. But for Buffy, it's that; I think we need to talk. It's exactly how he started the conversation, the very one sided conversation since he had already made up his mind about leaving. Adding a, "but not now and not here." Almost the same as the it can wait, he tells her, now.
Her heart sinks instantly. And though this might not be the sewers, it's still only them and a conversation (bad or good, she isn't sure) looming over her head. Slowly she sits up, trying to brace herself for the inevitable bad news that's going to follow. Except, oh that's right! He's going to keep it for a week! That has her bolting up, off the bed and turning to pace. Her mind is reeling, and not with anything good because she's trying to push away the memories of the last time they talked.
"You're damn right I'm not going to be able to concentrate! Not now and not tomorrow when I'm taking the test." She snaps, whirling around with Slayer speed and grace to face him. "God, what the hell, Angel? You can't do this. You can't just drop a bomb on me and expect me to hold it and not worry if it's going to blow my whole world up..." She manages to keep from saying, again! "Or if it's a dud and I worried myself for nothing." She explains, failing to keep her voice even. "So while it might not change for you if you hold onto it for another week, it's going to mess my week up. And I have enough crap on my plate, so you might as well tell me now." She demands, folding her arms over her chest and staring down at him, determined.
He sits up more slowly after she stands, watching as she paces around, all but yelling at him. OK, his choice of words was very poor. He waits for a break in her anger.
"I love you," he says evenly, staring up at her. He refuses to stand up, adding his size to the conversation and turning it into a confrontation. "There's more, but it's--well, it is important, but the main thing is, I love you. And I know you know that. I was wrong, in a lot of ways, when I broke up with you. I still..." Now he looks down at his hands, unable to watch her as he says the next. "I still think I made the right choice, leaving. Not just for you, but for me, too. But I let the mayor and your mother's visit rattle me, and I could've handled everything a lot better than I did."
Her eyes and mouth go wide, ready to protest whatever he's about to say to defend himself, when those three words hit her like a punch to the gut and she staggers back. Literally. The back of her knees hit the edge of the mattress and she slumps down on the bed once again, easing the tension, no longer of the offense.
"I..." Is all she manages to get out, stumbling over her words and her thoughts. What she wants to say is, I love you, too. And, I never stopped. But they get choked off at everything else he says.
And for the second time tonight, anger flares when she looks at him. Except it's not directed at him, though. "My mother?" She bites out, honing in for a second on that revelation. She knows what the Mayor said had gotten to him. It was meant to, so they'd be torn apart ─ divided ─ distracted. A plan B to his plan A. One that succeeded even if the other hadn't. But her mother? That she had no clue about. And her question makes it clear she wants to know what the visit entailed; she wants him to tell her.
"And what does that even mean? You were wrong in breaking up with me, but not leaving?" She asks, more annoyed at herself for not understanding, than at him. Maybe if he hadn't thrown so much at her all at once to process, she'd have been able to decipher it.
Angel winces. "She... She brought up the fact that... you're still young, and..." he really feels like he's throwing Joyce under the bus if he tells Buffy what was said, and he knows Joyce had good intentions. But looking back now, he recognizes that it was misguided, in more ways than one. Finally, he just sighs. "She didn't mean for it to play on my mind like it did, but after the mayor..."
"What I mean is, I think we—" he shakes his head; he's done deciding what's best for Buffy, even in hindsight. He does think it was best, in the long run, for them to be apart for a while, but he's not going to speak for her anymore. "Buffy. When I first saw you, the day you were called — if you'd seen me, you would've avoided me at least, and possibly called the cops on the creepy homeless guy.
"I will never regret meeting you. Or falling in love with you. But I've never... had a chance to be a good person, on my own, away from you, to prove that I could. I've never had friends at all until being with you, but it wasn't until I moved to LA that I had any friends that weren't yours first. At least, I'm assuming you don't wanna claim Cordelia or Wes as friends?"
He frowns a little, looking down at his hands in thought. "I needed to leave, to get perspective on us, and to learn how to be someone on my own. To know that I could be a good man, even if it wasn't for you. It's because of you, but it's not for you, anymore."
"When did she stop by to see you?" She asks coolly, so when she confronts her mother ─ and she will! ─ she isn't missing any details. It hurt bad enough when he did it himself ─ making calls for her without ever involving her. But to learn her mother has done the same, with him? She's livid. "What gave either of you the right to talk about my life, my future behind my back? To think you knew what was best for me?" Now some of her anger is thrown his way. She can't help it even if she tried. The wound from being shot down by him and the mess she was when picking up the pieces after he left still hurts. And so far this conversation has done nothing to help heal it; it's only reopened it.
Just when she thinks she's figured out where this is going, he does a complete 180, surprising her. The lump in her throat is painful as she tries to swallow it down, listening to him. Her first instinct is to tell him she would have never avoided him; that while she might not have known he was who she was always meant to be with, her heart did.
Loosening her grip on the blanket, thankful she hadn't torn it because what an explanation that would've been to Willow, she feels the corners of her mouth curving into a small smile. "To be fair, Wes was never a friend." She reasons. He was...tolerated company at best. Should she feel bad for thinking that way? Maybe. But she doesn't. It is what it is. "Cordelia, though? I guess you can have her. Only because I'm pretty sure Anya would have my head if I said Cordelia was one of us still." She's not joking. "Tell her I was reluctant in letting you claim her as a friend and I will make your life miserable. I'm talking glitter bombs and spamming your phone with chain texts."
Pushing up from the bed, she takes the chance while he's looking at his hands to gingerly cross the few steps over to her own bed, settling beside him. And although she wants to take his hand in hers, she keeps them folded in her lap, but her eyes on him. "I'd ask how that's working out for you..." Learning to be him on his own, "But I can see it. Even just an hour with you and I can see the space... it's been good for you." The same as it's been for her. And because she's always known he was a good man. She's glad he can see it now, too. "The other part, though. The us part, what about..." She leaves the question hanging in the air, afraid of asking and setting herself up for the let down.
Reaching up, Angel rubs at his forehead uncomfortably. He's not going to lie to her, though, and frankly he should've told her about it when it happened. Really, he should have discussed all this with her. But where Joyce had said Buffy had dealt with so much and had to grow up fast, even Joyce forgot that she was still just a girl sometimes - it was all Angel could ever think about. He loved her, and he wanted to protect her from the harsh realities of the world, which most definitely included himself, and he always tended to forget that Buffy already dealt with the harshness, every night. Her age, at this point, mattered about as much as his; where he was still making stupid decisions 250 years in, she was making the hard decisions after barely 18. He'd been right when he told Joyce they were from completely separate worlds; the difference was, Buffy's world was better, in large part because she made better choices than he did.
"Remember that night before Prom, we'd gotten back late and you fell asleep at the mansion? It was that next morning, she stopped by." He can't help the short, mirthless laugh when she questions what gave him the right to talk about her life behind her back, tipping his head back and scrubbing his hands over his face. "Arrogance," he says bleakly, still with a humorless smile playing faintly on his lips. "Not the first time my arrogance has damned me, probably won't be the last."
At her threats, he smiles wanly. "Deal." ...before his expression dips into mild confusion. "Even though I don't know what either of those are, I'm pretty sure I don't want to be on the receiving end."
He's going to tell her about the Day That Wasn't. But that is going to wait until after her exams. It will throw everything off and upset her too much, and not knowing isn't going to change anything, for the next week. "Doyle had a thing for Cordy, did I tell you that?" he asks quietly, looking at his hands again. "He didn't want to say anything, because she wasn't shy about her opinion that all demons are evil and 'gross'. Ken being such a nice guy and still trying to eat Doyle's brain didn't really help her opinion, and Doyle had his own issues with his demon side, so he just--didn't say anything. She found out─ on the last mission we had, where─." He takes a moment to breathe shakily, trying to center himself and get his emotions in check. "And I can't help but think... What if he'd told her? What's the worst that could've happened? She took a few weeks to be mad at him, before giving him a chance? Awkwardness around the office? I wish that's what happened, instead of the red eyes and kleenexes and sad looks when she thinks I can't see her. She went looking for Doyle's coffee mug, but he didn't have one, not a favorite one he always used, and she─ shouldn't he have one? Some tangible proof that he'd been there, something she could see..."
He sighs, rubbing his hand over his face again, before tilting his head to look at her sideways. "I love you. And I don't want something to happen, to either of us, and have the other regret... I don't know what us looks like, anymore. But I want... I want us back, whatever shape that is. We've done all, and we've done nothing, and I wanna see if we can strike a balance between the two."
no subject
Some people might say there's something almost as terrifying as a but followed a pause, and that's an, I think. Or some form of it like, I've been thinking. But for Buffy, it's that; I think we need to talk. It's exactly how he started the conversation, the very one sided conversation since he had already made up his mind about leaving. Adding a, "but not now and not here." Almost the same as the it can wait, he tells her, now.
Her heart sinks instantly. And though this might not be the sewers, it's still only them and a conversation (bad or good, she isn't sure) looming over her head. Slowly she sits up, trying to brace herself for the inevitable bad news that's going to follow. Except, oh that's right! He's going to keep it for a week! That has her bolting up, off the bed and turning to pace. Her mind is reeling, and not with anything good because she's trying to push away the memories of the last time they talked.
"You're damn right I'm not going to be able to concentrate! Not now and not tomorrow when I'm taking the test." She snaps, whirling around with Slayer speed and grace to face him. "God, what the hell, Angel? You can't do this. You can't just drop a bomb on me and expect me to hold it and not worry if it's going to blow my whole world up..." She manages to keep from saying, again! "Or if it's a dud and I worried myself for nothing." She explains, failing to keep her voice even. "So while it might not change for you if you hold onto it for another week, it's going to mess my week up. And I have enough crap on my plate, so you might as well tell me now." She demands, folding her arms over her chest and staring down at him, determined.
no subject
He sits up more slowly after she stands, watching as she paces around, all but yelling at him. OK, his choice of words was very poor. He waits for a break in her anger.
"I love you," he says evenly, staring up at her. He refuses to stand up, adding his size to the conversation and turning it into a confrontation. "There's more, but it's--well, it is important, but the main thing is, I love you. And I know you know that. I was wrong, in a lot of ways, when I broke up with you. I still..." Now he looks down at his hands, unable to watch her as he says the next. "I still think I made the right choice, leaving. Not just for you, but for me, too. But I let the mayor and your mother's visit rattle me, and I could've handled everything a lot better than I did."
no subject
"I..." Is all she manages to get out, stumbling over her words and her thoughts. What she wants to say is, I love you, too. And, I never stopped. But they get choked off at everything else he says.
And for the second time tonight, anger flares when she looks at him. Except it's not directed at him, though. "My mother?" She bites out, honing in for a second on that revelation. She knows what the Mayor said had gotten to him. It was meant to, so they'd be torn apart ─ divided ─ distracted. A plan B to his plan A. One that succeeded even if the other hadn't. But her mother? That she had no clue about. And her question makes it clear she wants to know what the visit entailed; she wants him to tell her.
"And what does that even mean? You were wrong in breaking up with me, but not leaving?" She asks, more annoyed at herself for not understanding, than at him. Maybe if he hadn't thrown so much at her all at once to process, she'd have been able to decipher it.
no subject
Angel winces. "She... She brought up the fact that... you're still young, and..." he really feels like he's throwing Joyce under the bus if he tells Buffy what was said, and he knows Joyce had good intentions. But looking back now, he recognizes that it was misguided, in more ways than one. Finally, he just sighs. "She didn't mean for it to play on my mind like it did, but after the mayor..."
"What I mean is, I think we—" he shakes his head; he's done deciding what's best for Buffy, even in hindsight. He does think it was best, in the long run, for them to be apart for a while, but he's not going to speak for her anymore. "Buffy. When I first saw you, the day you were called — if you'd seen me, you would've avoided me at least, and possibly called the cops on the creepy homeless guy.
"I will never regret meeting you. Or falling in love with you. But I've never... had a chance to be a good person, on my own, away from you, to prove that I could. I've never had friends at all until being with you, but it wasn't until I moved to LA that I had any friends that weren't yours first. At least, I'm assuming you don't wanna claim Cordelia or Wes as friends?"
He frowns a little, looking down at his hands in thought. "I needed to leave, to get perspective on us, and to learn how to be someone on my own. To know that I could be a good man, even if it wasn't for you. It's because of you, but it's not for you, anymore."
no subject
Just when she thinks she's figured out where this is going, he does a complete 180, surprising her. The lump in her throat is painful as she tries to swallow it down, listening to him. Her first instinct is to tell him she would have never avoided him; that while she might not have known he was who she was always meant to be with, her heart did.
Loosening her grip on the blanket, thankful she hadn't torn it because what an explanation that would've been to Willow, she feels the corners of her mouth curving into a small smile. "To be fair, Wes was never a friend." She reasons. He was...tolerated company at best. Should she feel bad for thinking that way? Maybe. But she doesn't. It is what it is. "Cordelia, though? I guess you can have her. Only because I'm pretty sure Anya would have my head if I said Cordelia was one of us still." She's not joking. "Tell her I was reluctant in letting you claim her as a friend and I will make your life miserable. I'm talking glitter bombs and spamming your phone with chain texts."
Pushing up from the bed, she takes the chance while he's looking at his hands to gingerly cross the few steps over to her own bed, settling beside him. And although she wants to take his hand in hers, she keeps them folded in her lap, but her eyes on him. "I'd ask how that's working out for you..." Learning to be him on his own, "But I can see it. Even just an hour with you and I can see the space... it's been good for you." The same as it's been for her. And because she's always known he was a good man. She's glad he can see it now, too. "The other part, though. The us part, what about..." She leaves the question hanging in the air, afraid of asking and setting herself up for the let down.
no subject
Reaching up, Angel rubs at his forehead uncomfortably. He's not going to lie to her, though, and frankly he should've told her about it when it happened. Really, he should have discussed all this with her. But where Joyce had said Buffy had dealt with so much and had to grow up fast, even Joyce forgot that she was still just a girl sometimes - it was all Angel could ever think about. He loved her, and he wanted to protect her from the harsh realities of the world, which most definitely included himself, and he always tended to forget that Buffy already dealt with the harshness, every night. Her age, at this point, mattered about as much as his; where he was still making stupid decisions 250 years in, she was making the hard decisions after barely 18. He'd been right when he told Joyce they were from completely separate worlds; the difference was, Buffy's world was better, in large part because she made better choices than he did.
"Remember that night before Prom, we'd gotten back late and you fell asleep at the mansion? It was that next morning, she stopped by." He can't help the short, mirthless laugh when she questions what gave him the right to talk about her life behind her back, tipping his head back and scrubbing his hands over his face. "Arrogance," he says bleakly, still with a humorless smile playing faintly on his lips. "Not the first time my arrogance has damned me, probably won't be the last."
At her threats, he smiles wanly. "Deal." ...before his expression dips into mild confusion. "Even though I don't know what either of those are, I'm pretty sure I don't want to be on the receiving end."
He's going to tell her about the Day That Wasn't. But that is going to wait until after her exams. It will throw everything off and upset her too much, and not knowing isn't going to change anything, for the next week. "Doyle had a thing for Cordy, did I tell you that?" he asks quietly, looking at his hands again. "He didn't want to say anything, because she wasn't shy about her opinion that all demons are evil and 'gross'. Ken being such a nice guy and still trying to eat Doyle's brain didn't really help her opinion, and Doyle had his own issues with his demon side, so he just--didn't say anything. She found out─ on the last mission we had, where─." He takes a moment to breathe shakily, trying to center himself and get his emotions in check. "And I can't help but think... What if he'd told her? What's the worst that could've happened? She took a few weeks to be mad at him, before giving him a chance? Awkwardness around the office? I wish that's what happened, instead of the red eyes and kleenexes and sad looks when she thinks I can't see her. She went looking for Doyle's coffee mug, but he didn't have one, not a favorite one he always used, and she─ shouldn't he have one? Some tangible proof that he'd been there, something she could see..."
He sighs, rubbing his hand over his face again, before tilting his head to look at her sideways. "I love you. And I don't want something to happen, to either of us, and have the other regret... I don't know what us looks like, anymore. But I want... I want us back, whatever shape that is. We've done all, and we've done nothing, and I wanna see if we can strike a balance between the two."